Hi DoctorTom.
Thanks for the feedback.
Joystick / controller preferences are all subjective. Everyone prefers one over the other. That's the way it should be.
As I mentioned in the show, I had both systems when they came out, as a kid. That said, I preferred the Intellivision controller over the Colecovision controller. To me, it was more comfortable in the hand, and more responsive. Was it perfect? No way. The internal mylar circuit matrixes would wear out over time (especially if you tended to press TOO HARD on the disc). Small cracks would develop, and the controller wouldn't respond properly.
Also, maybe you were running into the "can't use the keypad and disc at the same time" issue we discussed, which, if you didn't know that was a system limitation, would lead you to believe the controller was defective. I'm guessing these things could have been what lead you to say that the system was "unplayable because of the controllers". And what do you consider to be the Intellivision controller's "far greater limitations"?
We don't HATE other systems. I really like the Colecovision. I still have the original system I bought in 1982, along with all the expansion modules. However, when I play it, I prefer using the Super Action controllers, simply because the joystick is much more responsive. I'll even use a 2600 joystick if it's a single button / non-keypad game before using the original system controller. The stubby stick of the original controller just didn't work well, in my opinion. In a game like Smurf Rescue In Gargamel's Castle, you had to press UP or UP-RIGHT / UP-LEFT on the stick to jump. I can't tell you how many lives were lost simply because the joystick movement I was attempting to do didn't register.
And in games that used both side buttons, I found it very uncomfortable after a few minutes due to the placement of the side buttons, and the size and shape of the controller. Again, my opinion. I'm sure others didn't have a problem with it.
I know a lot of people dislike the Intellivision controller. That's fine. I, however, found it to be a good match for the system and it's games. It can cause your "disc thumb" to get sore after a while, and sometimes your fingers can also become a little tender after heavy side button use. But I don't know any controller around that doesn't cause similar symptoms.
So, on this issue, I guess we agree to disagree.
-Paul