Back in the day it wasn't so bad. But the buttons would always break. Missle command never worked. Even at a relatives house never got it to work. I always wondered how you were supposed to play the game. That was until I got a used 5200 off ebay. Now I can play missle command. But anyway the stock controllers were great except for the buttons refusing to work after 1000 presses or so. I even played frogger and got through like 4 or 5 levels or something like that. But now I can't stand it. Either that or my controllers are in need of a gold rebuild.
Anyhow as for the wico the pointy thing is not bad. And for some games like frogger the wico is much better. Plus. it was only 20 dollars on ebay. So It was no big deal.
But I hate buttons are on the left instead of the right. And a rubber band does not keep them pressed. Maybe a competition pro 5000 would help or an atari masterplay, but it is so hard to find those. even on ebay.