Most ANY arcade game translation that was made was enough to get my mouth watering to play it.
I wasn't too hip on the original titles. However Mspacman, Frogger, Qbert, Defender, Pacman *cough*, Donkey Kong, Asteroids, Reactor etc. etc. would get me all up and daydreaming as to how close they would come to the real arcade game. Of course often they would be waay off and dissapointing (pacman/donkey kong). But occasionally they would hit just the right balance of gameplay to make you think you could play the arcade game just as well with the acquired skills (Frogger, Mspac, Reactor). I remember ordering Asteroids from the Sears wishbook and dreaming about it nightly until I got it