Thanks, Mitkraft. I was reading all of the responses the last couple of days, and I couldn't believe the people who were justifying theft.
Let's be clear - this is theft. The poster got home with an item that he did not pay for, and he kept it with no intention of going back and paying for it. What's the difference between what he did and flat out shoplifting? If he came in here bragging about stealing an item from a retail store, would he be defended to this level? Even worse, he stole from a non-profit. One justification from another member is that it's OK because the CEO makes a lot of money? Another justification is that Goodwill.com charges high shipping costs? How does any of that make it ok to steal from them?
I seriously thought that he'd be piled on until he was ashamed enough to go back and do what's right. Instead, I'm a bit sickened by the defenders of him. Stealing isn't OK. Stealing from a non-profit is reprehensible.