At the end of the day, this is a senseless discussion. It's comparing apples and oranges.
I for myself am a big Atari 2600 homebrew lover, because I am fascinated by the results a (mostly single) programmer person can achieve out of a 50 year old hardware, especially with its hardcore technical and gameplay limitations. This makes me love games like Galagon, Thrust+, Medieval Mayhem or Tower of Rubble even more! There's no way I could make a next-gen enthusiast catch fire for this. And it's totally understandable, too.